Belle Rogers, a renovator known online as @bydesignermum, was asked by the Newark and Sherwood District Council to take down her wooden pergola not once, but twice. Despite creating a movable structure complying with height and coverage rules, her Grade II listed home’s protected status meant stricter planning permission rules applied.
- Permitted development rules are stricter for listed buildings.
- Movable garden structures may still require planning permission.
- Conservation area officers can judge features as intrusive.
What happened
Belle Rogers, known on social media as @bydesignermum, installed a wooden pergola in her Nottingham garden in 2021 as a finishing touch during the pandemic. While pergolas usually fall under permitted development rights that do not require planning permission—especially if they cover less than half the garden and stay below specific height limits—Belle’s home is a Grade II listed property within a conservation area, subjecting it to stricter rules. After an anonymous complaint, local authorities deemed her pergola a permanent structure attached to the building and asked her to remove it.
In response, Belle took down the first pergola and later built a movable, freestanding version on wheels to comply with council guidelines. However, despite this adjustment, the council again requested its removal by August 2026, citing that the new pergola remained an ‘intrusive feature’ impacting the listed building’s character. The case highlights how even experienced renovators can be caught off guard by the nuanced planning restrictions surrounding protected properties.
Why it feels good
This story serves as a reminder of the important balance between preserving heritage and allowing homeowners to enhance their outdoor living spaces. While the decisions might feel frustrating, they come from a genuine effort to protect the unique historical character of listed buildings and conservation areas. Community input and council oversight ensure these special sites maintain their distinct charm for future generations.
Belle’s willingness to adapt by making the pergola movable shows respect for the rules and a positive approach to resolving conflicts. Her openness in sharing the experience online has raised awareness about often overlooked planning considerations. For many homeowners of listed properties, it reinforces the value of checking local regulations carefully while encouraging creativity within those boundaries.
What to enjoy or watch next
If you are inspired by Belle’s garden ideas and her perseverance, consider exploring her social channels @bydesignermum on TikTok and Instagram, where she shares home renovation tips, garden inspiration, and practical DIY projects. Following such content can provide valuable lessons on working sensitively with heritage homes while creating stylish outdoor spaces.
For anyone planning garden structures, start by reviewing your local planning rules, especially if you live near protected buildings or in conservation zones. Resources like Ideal Home offer accessible guides to help homeowners understand permitted development rights and when to seek official permissions. Staying informed will help you enjoy your home improvements with confidence and peace of mind.